Home to the pristine Lake Otsego and the prestigious National Baseball Hall of Fame, Cooperstown is the best countryside escape from the dizzying hustle and bustle of the metropolis.
An incredible destination to indulge in rural traditions, riveting historic trivia, and an abundance of period-style architecture, Cooperstown welcomes travelers to enjoy countryside pleasures and connect with the wilderness.
Travelers can explore charming craft shops, family-run dining establishments, and green forests brimming with walkable trails.
This quaint and charming town offers an array of historic inns and grand boutique hotels with sprawling private estates to enjoy a rejuvenating retreat. Here are the best cool and unusual hotels in Cooperstown, New York (in no particular order)...
1. The Otesaga Resort Hotel – a beautiful and elegant upscale resort hotel housed in a historic federal-style property
The Otesaga Resort Hotel welcomes vacationers to revel in the grandeur and charm of its restorative estate, adorned with historic heritage accents and sophisticated furniture. This opulent retreat combines old-fashioned traditions with high-end resort amenities to immerse in the splendors of the countryside.
Guests can explore a selection of gracefully adorned lakeview accommodations trimmed with exquisite furniture, polished floors, and in-room appliances. The resort is home to an award-winning Leatherstocking golf course, and the proximity to the picturesque Lake Otsego makes it ideal for boating and fishing adventures.
This historic hotel offers a fabulous location to explore popular tourist attractions, including the Farmer’s Museum, the Fenimore Art Museum, and the Baseball Hall of Fame.
- To book, check prices or availability for The Otesaga Resort Hotel
2. Landmark Inn – a cozy and charming 19th-century B&B that is the perfect home away from home
An urbane boutique hotel nestled in the heart of Cooperstown’s historic quarters, the Landmark Inn offers a tranquil atmosphere for a relaxing getaway.
Originally constructed in 1856, the Landmark Inn has undergone numerous modern upgrades without losing its traditional Victorian charm and period-style finishing.
The inn is home to 11 artistically crafted guest rooms featuring feather duvets on finely crafted beds, in-room appliances, and spa-like bathrooms with multi-jet showers.
The inn is always redolent with the aroma of freshly baked cookies, and guests cannot stop raving about the full-course gourmet breakfast served in the idyllic dining room.
Landmark Inn offers a delightfully romantic ambiance for honeymoons and dreamy retreats without losing touch with modern tourist attractions.
- To book, check prices or availability for Landmark Inn
3. The Railroad Inn – a quirky and trendy property listed on the National Register of Historic Places in the Glimmerglass Historic District
The Railroad Inn is an 1890 landmark site registered in the National Register of Historic Places, retaining its Victorian-era grace and poise with remarkable modern upgrades and thoughtfully preserved period-style interiors. Situated in the heart of the Glimmerglass Historic District, this celebrated venue is surrounded by cultural charm and heritage.
The inn has a free-spirited vibe that encourages one to relax in the soothing environment created by the sparsely furnished, sophisticated design aesthetic. This distinguished boutique hotel is home to 22 handsomely styled guest rooms and suites decorated with unique railroad-themed fixtures and modern amenities.
The onsite Hard Ball Café serves traditional American fare with an annually updated, seasonal menu.
- To book, check prices or availability for The Railroad Inn
4. The Tunnicliff Inn – a cute quirky-chic inn that blends history and style
Ideally located in the action-packed downtown area, the Tunnicliff Inn is a historic inn that first opened its doors in 1802 as a general store and residence.
One of the oldest buildings in Cooperstone, this hotel has classic Federal townhome-style architecture and beautifully preserved interiors. It was transformed into the Tunnicliff Inn in 1916, and since then, it has served Cooperstown’s hospitality sector with unmatched and unwavering dedication.
This enchanting inn offers 17 gracefully adorned rooms, including executive suites, with private bathrooms, in-room appliances, premium toiletries, and designated workstations. Guests enjoy access to multiple indoor and outdoor seating areas and an onsite restaurant famous for its inventive continental cuisine.
- To book, check prices or availability for The Tunnicliff Inn
5. Cooperstown Bed and Breakfast – a recently renovated Edwardian B&B close to popular attractions
A traditional 1902 bed and breakfast situated on the charming Chestnut Street, this beautiful Edwardian building is a short stroll away from the hip restaurants and boutiques on Main Street and a 15-minute walk from Lake Otsego.
This lovely tree-lined neighborhood is brimming with head-turning Edwardian and Victorian architecture, and the Cooperstown Bed and Breakfast pays homage to the area’s period buildings with dramatic aplomb. Guests can explore lovingly curated living and lounging spaces, featuring rotating art showcases of handpicked pieces and rarities.
The luxuriously adorned accommodations include spacious rooms and family-friendly one and two-bedroom suites, featuring multiple beds, smart appliances, free WiFi, and luxury linens.
- To book, check prices or availability for Cooperstown Bed and Breakfast
6. Cobblescote on the Lake – an iconic Dutch Colonial-style lake-side inn that provides a peaceful setting where you can unplug and unwind
A resplendent waterfront country home perched on the western banks of Lake Otsego, Cobblescote on the Lake curates a magnificent experience with its family-oriented values and thoughtful hospitality traditions.
This historic inn has served Cooperstown’s hospitality sector since 1984, and the guest rooms have undergone extensive renovations to install innovative amenities and contemporary furniture. The villa offers an array of beautifully bedecked guest rooms and two Carriage House studios featuring fully-equipped kitchens.
The interiors are inspired by the arts and crafts movement that gripped America during the early 1900s, featuring ornate period-themed furniture and traditional accents, such as walnut wood paneling and colonial Dutch-style finishing.
Guests awaken to the divine aroma of freshly-made breakfast, served on the lovely lakefront deck.
- To book, check prices or availability for Cobblescote on the Lake
7. Tentrr Signature Site – Mount Sibley – a cool and unique upscale glamping experience that offers a distinctive and unforgettable experience
An adventurous wilderness retreat with a secluded setting to escape the maddening crowds, the Tentrr Signature Site welcomes nature lovers to revel in the lush greenery of Mount Sibley. Sprawling over 40 acres of untampered and wild natural beauty, this whimsical site is the perfect place to find serenity and connect with Mother Nature.
The Tentrr site offers a 120-square-feet dome-like canvas tent placed on an elevated wooden platform, featuring a queen-size bed and ample space to set up multiple sleeping bags. The campsite provides camping chairs, an outdoor fire pit, a propane grill, and a picnic table for outdoor dining.
- To book, check prices or availability for Tentrr Signature Site – Mount Sibley
8. Whisperin’ Pines Chalet – a rustic-chic Swiss-style chalet perfect for a unique romantic stay
Home to old-fashioned European opulence and a serene rural setting, the Whisperin’ Pines is a grand Swiss-style chalet nestled in the heart of the verdant wilderness. This sumptuously adorned estate is home to a private nature trail and an enchanting stream with two cascading waterfalls.
The Whisperin’ Pines offers an impressive lineup of open concept suites, each uniquely designed and decorated to deliver a themed experience. For instance, the Honeymoon Suite is a palatial-style accommodation with cathedral ceilings, a luxurious California king-size canopy bed, an expansive private balcony, a marble-clad bathroom, and rich cherry wood accents.
Situated near a heavenly babbling brook, the beautifully manicured grounds have calmative energy that soothes the mind and soul.
- To book, check prices or availability for Whisperin’ Pines Chalet
9. The White House Inn – a high-end country-house-style retreat located in the heart of Cooperstown’s historic district
The White House Inn is ideally located in the action-packed historic quarters, surrounded by Cooperstown’s finest restaurant and entertainment venues. This Greek Revival property was originally built in 1835, and the magnificently restored interiors are lined with historic relics, beautiful antiques, and fascinating memorabilia.
The White House Inn is home to 21 strikingly adorned guest rooms with ensuite bathrooms, smart appliances, and comfortable bedding. The Carriage House offers a more intimate setting, ideal for honeymooners and families. The two-bedroom rental comes with a fully equipped kitchenette, a living room, private bathrooms, and a deck overlooking the Jacuzzi pool.
Guests enjoy mingling with like-minded travelers over the complimentary gourmet breakfast served in the Gathering Room.
- To book, check prices or availability for The White House Inn
10. Lake Front Hotel – a laid-back family-run motel based at the foot of the Otsego Lake
Gracefully perched on the southern tip of the picturesque Lake Otsego, the Lake Front Hotel is a centrally-located accommodation famous for its spectacular lake view rooms and close proximity to Cooperstown Village.
The Lake Front Hotel is a family-friendly site to enjoy a well-rounded Cooperstown vacation, home to the only boat tour service in town, the Glimmerglass Queen, offering seasonal tours and personalized boat parties.
The extensive lineup of accommodations includes standard rooms with queen and king-size beds, deluxe units, deluxe waterfront units, and waterfront suites with private bay view balconies.
The onsite restaurant has a quirky nautical theme, a wave wall bar, and a refined dining space overlooking the scenic Lake Otsego.
- To book, check prices or availability for Lake Front Hotel
11. Rose & Thistle Bed & Breakfast – a traditional Victorian B&B housed in a pink turn-of-the-century property with a wraparound porch
An enthralling Victorian-style bed & breakfast nestled in the heart of all the action and entertainment, the Rose & Thistle is the ideal base to enjoy the best of Cooperstown.
This cozy B&B is situated near numerous popular attractions, including the Glimmerglass State Park, the Farmers Museum, the Baseball Hall of Fame, and the Fenimore Art Museum.
The bedrooms play up an alluring blend of old-world glamor infused with innovative amenities to deliver top-notch comfort and convenience. The accommodations offer in-room appliances, fine bedding, air conditioning, and ensuite bathrooms.
Guests speak highly of the country-style breakfast spread served every morning.
- To book, check prices or availability for Rose & Thistle Bed & Breakfast
12. Visions Inn – a quaint and quirky-chic inn housed in a former 19th-century brewery
Erected in a 19th-century building that formerly housed a brewery, the Visions Inn is situated a stone’s throw away from Lake Otsego and central Cooperstown attractions.
This sophisticated venue offers an array of efficient and family-friendly accommodations, including Queen Rooms, Suites, and Family Rooms.
The thoughtfully designed rooms and suites feature an array of convenience-enhancing amenities, premium bedding, entertainment facilities, and toiletries. The suites and family rooms are ideal for large groups, offering spacious bedrooms and lounging areas to enjoy a comfortable stay.
The Visions Inn is a conveniently located site to plan hassle-free day trips to Glimmerglass State Park, Doubleday Field, and local breweries.
- To book, check prices or availability for Visions Inn
We also have posts on…
- Cool boutique hotels in Albany
- Cool boutique hotels in Lake Placid
- Cool boutique hotels in Finger Lakes
- Cool boutique hotels in Buffalo
- Cool boutique hotels in Woodstock
- Cool boutique hotels in Detroit
- Cool boutique hotels in Ottawa
My first true adventure began as a six month voyage around South East Asia as a fresh faced backpacker and ever since I’ve lived a semi nomadic existence, clocking up visits to over 40 countries. I’m a lover of US Road Trips, deserted beaches bathed in warm glow of a sunset, Cuban mojitos, travel destinations far away from the tourist crowds and all things Scandinavian – from cloudberry liquors to Nordic noirs. When not wandering the world and running Global Grasshopper, you’ll find me walking my rescued Greek street dog in leafy South West London, strolling around the Brighton Lanes on random day trips, hunting for photogenic landscapes or daydreaming about my favourite places; Havana, Copenhagen, Italy, Laos, California and the surreally beautiful landscapes of a wintry Iceland.